Jump to content

User:Chaosdruid/frtrialquestersult

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
From spreadsheet - end calcs are 44.8% written as 0.448 etc.


A 2:1 for FR on BLP, Expiry on rest 66% consenssus
B 2:1 against FR all articles 66% consensus
C 2:1 against FR and SP on BLP 66% consensus
D 1.7:1 for FR all BLP 63% consensus
E 1:1 deadlock SP all BLP 50%
FvG 2:1 Leave V do something 66% consensus

I don't really understand how there are 548 unique - I make the tots Jan10=823 Jan17=923 = 1746 Gtot

If I add up all the votes:-
A+C+F+G = 169 out of 1746 = 12% (ignore)
B+D+E = 1577 out of tot = 88%

That means 88% of the people voted 88% consensus to protect the pages with either SP or FR with 3 ways of doing it.

And looks like
B+D (FR all+ Fr BLP) = 47% of tot vote
D+E (SP/FR all BLP) = 69% of tot vote

So, we have a consensus that we will either SP/FR all BLP from this voting table
So, what the hell are we arguing about ?? there we have a 69% consensus to protect all BLP, and all we have to do is decide which way

1 SP means users cannot edit - it will put people off and is against the spirit and aims of WIki
2 FR means people can edit, but it won't be final till approved

I vote for FR on all BLP

It's time to accept that we all have to get along and make this what it should be - a debate for betterment of WikiWorld.
Chaosdruid (talk) 05:06, 23 January 2009 (UTC)